• Welcome to the Heroscapers 2.0 site! We've still got some dust to clear and adjustments to make, including launching a new front page, but we hope you enjoy the improvements to the site. Please post your feedback and any issues you encounter in this thread.

Fan Fic Contest - Are you the best writer?

Nope. The general rule is just "make a good faith effort." It was a lot easier when we were all kids, but now submitting short stories in an online forum takes back seat priority to...adulting so we just wait for all submissions to come in and then judge.

Admittedly, the pressure is kinda on you since you're the last one to throw your hat in the ring. :D

Fair enough! Fwiw I should have something submitted within days/weeks, not months, if that helps.
 
Nope. The general rule is just "make a good faith effort." It was a lot easier when we were all kids, but now submitting short stories in an online forum takes back seat priority to...adulting so we just wait for all submissions to come in and then judge.

Admittedly, the pressure is kinda on you since you're the last one to throw your hat in the ring. :D

Fair enough! Fwiw I should have something submitted within days/weeks, not months, if that helps.

You're good man. We just care about a good contest.
 
Nope. The general rule is just "make a good faith effort." It was a lot easier when we were all kids, but now submitting short stories in an online forum takes back seat priority to...adulting so we just wait for all submissions to come in and then judge.

Admittedly, the pressure is kinda on you since you're the last one to throw your hat in the ring. :D

Fair enough! Fwiw I should have something submitted within days/weeks, not months, if that helps.

You're good man. We just care about a good contest.

Indeed; this'll be the first time we've had four entries in I can't even remember how long.

~TGRF.
 
I'll edit mine then too. A small change only—I kinda forgot that one of the included Heroscape characters famously has an eye patch.

~TAF
 
I'm finished! This contest lined up nicely with the NGC Unit Design Contest, so I already had a new design ready to go, and it felt worthwhile to flesh out the backstory. For reference, the unit card and description is here.

I've taken the trouble of formatting it for Heroscapers since I will probably add it to the growing catalogue of Myths of Valhalla after the contest.

Brilliance

Spoiler Alert!
 
Right then. If anyone else needs to edit their stories, speak now. Otherwise I will likely read these tomorrow, and judge either tomorrow or the next day (depending on how long winded certain of us are). ;)

~TGRF.
 
I have read the stories and come to my decision. Honestly it was a tight race all around, and the designs were great. I've judged the stories based on two factors: the design and the story. Let's get to it (note that there are severe spoilers - if you intend to read the stories, do so first):

Third Place

Spoiler Alert!


Second Place

Spoiler Alert!


First Place

Spoiler Alert!


It was a tough call, but there you have it. I'm happy to offer more in-detail thoughts on your entry if you want, but I warn you that I will be brutally honest. For now I await the next prompt!

~TGRF.
 
Wow, thanks. That was basically the Dark Healer from my RPG in a nutshell and warp speed. Those are all actual abilities of the class.
The change in personality and growing insanities are also part of the gig.
The main thing I never mentioned was that if there was no victim, Kelda takes the damage but far worse than what she absorbed. In the end I did not want her going out quite like that, at least not on paper.
What I liked about Kelda is that she does have that possible negative part of her healing that really made her fit even better. Also to become a Dark Healer, one is usually good/lawful (no traditional alignments but a sliding scale of law/chaos) which also fit nicely.
 
Damn -1 title. At least now I don't need to hesitate so much about entering any prompt out of fear of the record.

To answer your plot question, the ground only needed to be fed with warfare up until a certain point when it could manifest properly: like a quota. At that point battle was no longer needed. I guess it wasn't clarified especially well. There was also an idea that the wellsprings would summon the dead from other worlds on their own to maintain self-feeding, hence the "die in battle = go to Valhalla" religious connection on Earth. But it was too late to add that in. The idea needed some more time in the oven to cook thoroughly.

You may prompt when ready, T.

~TAF
 
Damn -1 title. At least now I don't need to hesitate so much about entering any prompt out of fear of the record.

~TAF

You've got a ways to go before you lose the title. Your average is 1.167. The next closest is 1.5.

~TGRF, eagerly awaiting the next prompt.
 
I think I have it. Let me mull it a bit longer though and double check it has not been used before.
 
I think I have it. Let me mull it a bit longer though and double check it has not been used before.
The Index has all the prompts listed under the 'Competitive' tab; that should make it easier to check. You'll need to scroll to the side a bit. Looking forward to it.

~TGRF.
 
Ok, could not find that list so going to hope this has not been done before.

A Wellspring gets all cool and glow-y as a portal opens beneath its surface. From the pool emerges Valhalla's newest resident, you.

You have been summoned. Why? Perhaps your knowledge of Valhalla?
Who knows. Did you swallow some special water and is that now changing you on a molecular level? Maybe?

Feel free to use your knowledge of Scape to your advantage and take some stuff with you. You only have the knowledge you would have but perhaps the Wellspring has given you other abilities.
 
Ok, could not find that list so going to hope this has not been done before.

A Wellspring gets all cool and glow-y as a portal opens beneath its surface. From the pool emerges Valhalla's newest resident, you.

You have been summoned. Why? Perhaps your knowledge of Valhalla?

Who knows. Did you swallow some special water and is that now changing you on a molecular level? Maybe?

Feel free to use your knowledge of Scape to your advantage and take some stuff with you. You only have the knowledge you would have but perhaps the Wellspring has given you other abilities.

Hmm. I tried to write this story once and it was terrible. Definitely an interesting prompt, Tornado, I'll see what springs to mind.

~TGRF.
 
I've already chronicled the adventures of the comically obvious self-insert gary-stu Avarius Fantus. I might be able to use that or come up with something similar, though if I do expect something short and very tongue-in-cheek.

~TAF, who has a prompt too good to lose now
 
Damn -1 title. At least now I don't need to hesitate so much about entering any prompt out of fear of the record.

To answer your plot question, the ground only needed to be fed with warfare up until a certain point when it could manifest properly: like a quota. At that point battle was no longer needed. I guess it wasn't clarified especially well. There was also an idea that the wellsprings would summon the dead from other worlds on their own to maintain self-feeding, hence the "die in battle = go to Valhalla" religious connection on Earth. But it was too late to add that in. The idea needed some more time in the oven to cook thoroughly.

You may prompt when ready, T.

~TAF

The quota thing was clear to me, but they are 10k word prompts and TGRF had to read them all at once. It's understandable a few things slipped through the cracks. I guess we need to keep that in mind when writing for a judge vs the wider community.

@TGRF In the same line of reasoning, you're right, I probably should have made the story more about the design and the magic and how the magic is pulled from the realms etc etc...because it's you :p, Mr. Technical. The main conflict in the story was meant to be Ruddy's interaction with his master but I think I spent too much time on the design and not enough developing the relationship and tension between Ruddy and Finarion Starweaver.

Well judged as always. Looking forward to reading your submission for the next one.
 
@TGRF In the same line of reasoning, you're right, I probably should have made the story more about the design and the magic and how the magic is pulled from the realms etc etc...because it's you :p, Mr. Technical. The main conflict in the story was meant to be Ruddy's interaction with his master but I think I spent too much time on the design and not enough developing the relationship and tension between Ruddy and Finarion Starweaver.

Well judged as always. Looking forward to reading your submission for the next one.

I did definitely like your magic system - it felt like something which could yield a really cool world. I did get the relationship between Ruddy and Finarion - though I'll agree it was light - it was really just me not knowing what was possible in the final duel. It was written as a big epic duel and pivotal moment for Ruddy, but because he'd just found a way to use magic to do whatever he wanted until that point, I had no context for how or why Finarion was more powerful and such a threat, and why Ruddy couldn't just turn him into a gnat or something.

~TGRF.
 
@TGRF In the same line of reasoning, you're right, I probably should have made the story more about the design and the magic and how the magic is pulled from the realms etc etc...because it's you :p, Mr. Technical. The main conflict in the story was meant to be Ruddy's interaction with his master but I think I spent too much time on the design and not enough developing the relationship and tension between Ruddy and Finarion Starweaver.

Well judged as always. Looking forward to reading your submission for the next one.

I did definitely like your magic system - it felt like something which could yield a really cool world. I did get the relationship between Ruddy and Finarion - though I'll agree it was light - it was really just me not knowing what was possible in the final duel. It was written as a big epic duel and pivotal moment for Ruddy, but because he'd just found a way to use magic to do whatever he wanted until that point, I had no context for how or why Finarion was more powerful and such a threat, and why Ruddy couldn't just turn him into a gnat or something.

~TGRF.

Ohhh, that makes way more sense.
 
Ooh, I have a great idea. It'll take some work to flesh out, but I'm really excited about this one. Bring the competition!

~TGRF.
 

Hey, so do the entries all have to be 100% separate from each other? There's just so much more I can do with the character from the last prompt, so I'm working on a draft for this prompt as a sequel to my last entry.

I will add a couple things.

1. They are different enough that you do not really need context from the first entry.

2. They are completely different stories with some shared characters and set in the same world.
 

Hey, so do the entries all have to be 100% separate from each other? There's just so much more I can do with the character from the last prompt, so I'm working on a draft for this prompt as a sequel to my last entry.

I will add a couple things.

1. They are different enough that you do not really need context from the first entry.

2. They are completely different stories with some shared characters and set in the same world.

The only rule is that you don't submit something you've previously written. I've used past characters plenty. Tornado can of course provide additional limitations if he wants.

~TGRF.
 
Back
Top