If Jotun throws a figure into swamp water, does it have to roll for throwing damage?
The rulebook says that any power that refers to water also means swamp water, but it also says swamp water does not negate falling damage.
I think this is one of those "letter of the rule vs. spirit of the rule" things, so I'm not sure.![]()
I would definately say roll for damage.
Did someone just divide by zero? Is the world coming to an end?I would definately say roll for damage.
It's OK, Billy.Did someone just divide by zero? Is the world coming to an end?
I'm scared.
Hold me.
Swamp water is water but water is not swamp water, eh?
Final answer!Swamp water is water but water is not swamp water, eh?
What is this an SAT question?
Which of the following statements are true?
A-All swamp water is water but all water is not swamp water.
B-All swamp water is water and all water is swamp water.
C-Onacara is a pretty funny guy even when he is making fun of me.
D-A and C but not B
E-All of the above.
If Jotun throws a figure into swamp water, does it have to roll for throwing damage?
The rulebook says that any power that refers to water also means swamp water, but it also says swamp water does not negate falling damage.
I think this is one of those "letter of the rule vs. spirit of the rule" things, so I'm not sure.![]()
Final answer!Swamp water is water but water is not swamp water, eh?
What is this an SAT question?
Which of the following statements are true?
A-All swamp water is water but all water is not swamp water.
B-All swamp water is water and all water is swamp water.
C-Onacara is a pretty funny guy even when he is making fun of me.
D-A and C but not B
E-All of the above.
If Jotun throws a figure into swamp water, does it have to roll for throwing damage?
The rulebook says that any power that refers to water also means swamp water, but it also says swamp water does not negate falling damage.
I think this is one of those "letter of the rule vs. spirit of the rule" things, so I'm not sure.![]()
The "letter of the rule" says swamp water is treated as water for all purposes except falling damage and it can be walked through. This would mean there is no roll for damage if Jotun throws into swamp water.
The "spirit of the rule" is forcing the opponent to roll for damage?Isn't the "spirit of the rule" usually translated into "give the guy a break", not "nuh uh, you're rolling for damage!"...
Bring him in...I need more backup.You roll for damage when Juton throws onto swamp water. Do I need to sic theGuru on this thread?
Just C.
So does every water related ability work on swamp water? Like water elemental's water tunnel? Or Sauhagin(idk how to spell it lol) raider's water bonus? Or Ewashua's twister special attack? Because if it doesn't count as water when moving or falling, but DOES count as water with microcorp agent's ability, I feel like it would work for every water ability that doesn't specify not swamp waterWHile not Microcorp related, swamp-water is a bit confusing... it's water for the Microcorp, but not water for falling... or for moving. That is, you can move through water without stopping and you take falling damage if you fall into it.
YesSo does every water related ability work on swamp water? Like water elemental's water tunnel? Or Sauhagin(idk how to spell it lol) raider's water bonus? Or Ewashua's twister special attack? Because if it doesn't count as water when moving or falling, but DOES count as water with microcorp agent's ability, I feel like it would work for every water ability that doesn't specify not swamp water
Awesome. Thanks